Top 10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Credentialing Partner

If we are to talk about the importance of credentialing in the simplest way, then it is the one that decides whether your clinic runs smoothly or struggles every single day. It controls how fast a new doctor can start working, whether claims get paid on time, and whether patients feel confident that they’re in safe hands.

Moreover, credentialing never stands still; its rules keep changing. Medicare Advantage adds new requirements, Medicaid varies from one state to another, and commercial payers rewrite their processes as quickly as they adjust their contracts. What worked five years ago is often useless today. That’s why this blog explores:

• What credentialing is
• Why clinics need it
• The biggest credentialing challenges clinics face
• The pros and cons of in-house vs. outsourced credentialing, and
• The top 10 questions every clinic must ask before choosing a credentialing partner

Let’s begin.

Understanding Credentialing in Clinics

Credentialing is the process of verifying that a healthcare provider is qualified, properly trained, and legally allowed to practice in their state and specialty. It ensures patients receive care from competent professionals while allowing clinics to remain compliant and eligible for insurance reimbursements. The process usually includes:

• Education Verification: Confirming medical school, residency, or fellowship completion
• Licensure Check: Making sure providers hold an active, valid license
• Board Certification: Verifying specialty-specific qualifications
• Work History & References: Reviewing past employment or hospital privileges
• Background Checks: Screening for malpractice claims or disciplinary actions
• Insurance Enrollment: Enrolling providers ‘in-network’ so clinics can bill and get reimbursed

Since credentialing is not a one-time event, most insurers and hospitals require re-credentialing every two to three years to confirm providers continue to meet standards. The process can take 90 to 120 days, sometimes longer, and includes:

• Application Submission: The provider or clinic submits detailed applications with all personal, educational, and professional information.
• Primary Source Verification (PSV): Insurers and credentialing bodies contact schools, boards, and employers directly to verify information.
• Payer Enrollment: Once verified, the provider is added to payer networks so the clinic can bill insurance companies.
• Approval & Privileging: In hospital settings, credentialing also determines what procedures the provider is authorized to perform.
• Re-Credentialing: Every 2 to 3 years, providers must go through the process again.

This may sound straightforward, but each payer (Medicare, Medicaid, Blue Cross, Aetna, etc.) has its own forms and timelines, making it a time-consuming administrative burden.

Credentialing Nightmares No One Talks About

• Long Timelines: Clinics often wait 3 to 4 months for approvals, delaying revenue.
• Administrative Burden: The paperwork is extensive and error-prone.
• Changing Regulations: Requirements vary by state and are updated frequently.
• Coordination Issues: Multiple payers mean multiple submissions and follow-ups.
• Revenue Impact: If credentialing is delayed, providers can’t bill, creating cash-flow problems.

These challenges often bottleneck operations and revenue, raising the question of whether to manage credentialing in-house with limited bandwidth or shift it to specialists equipped for speed, compliance, and scale.

In-House Strengths Versus Outsourced Advantages in Credentialing

Credentialing sits right at the point where compliance, provider readiness, and practice growth meet. For every clinic, the real question is how to do it.

When you keep it in-house, you get the comfort of familiarity and the ability to watch over the process closely. Your team already knows the workflows, and it can feel reassuring to have that direct control. The challenge is that those same staff members often end up pulled away from patients or revenue-focused work to chase down renewals or deal with paperwork. What feels like staying in control can slowly become a drain on time and energy.

When you outsource, you hand the work to specialists who do this all day, every day. Their systems are built for speed, accuracy, and compliance, which means faster onboarding and fewer bottlenecks. At the same time, you give up some of the control you had in-house. You are relying on a vendor’s process and placing sensitive provider information in their hands.

So the decision really comes down to what matters most for your clinic. Do you value the comfort of keeping things close, or do you want the efficiency and expertise of an external partner? Below, we’ve highlighted the main advantages and challenges that most clinics consider before choosing a credentialing path.

Pros of Outsourcing

• Expertise: Vendors specialize in navigating payer requirements.
• Efficiency: Faster turnaround times.
• Cost Savings: Hiring full-time staff may cost more than outsourcing.
• Technology: Many vendors use advanced software for tracking and compliance.
• Scalability: Easy to handle multiple providers across multiple states.

Cons of Outsourcing

• Control Issues: Clinics rely on third parties to manage sensitive processes.
• Data Security Risks: Sensitive provider data is shared outside the clinic.
• Cost Transparency: Some vendors charge hidden fees.
• Vendor Dependency: Switching vendors can disrupt workflows.

No doubt, there are risks to think about, like vendor dependency, hidden costs, and the need to share sensitive data. But these are not deal breakers; they are guideposts that help shape the decision.

When you ask the right questions and set up clear accountability, outsourcing no longer feels like giving up control. Instead, it becomes a structured way to keep oversight while gaining the speed and efficiency that specialists bring.

Top 10 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Credentialing Vendor

#1 What’s included in your credentialing service?

Why this question matters: Credentialing extends payer enrollment; it involves CAQH, NPI, PECOS, Medicare/Medicaid registration, commercial insurance paneling, ERA/EFT setups, re-credentialing, and frequent change-of-information updates. Many vendors only cover pieces of this puzzle.

What to look for: A vendor who clearly states they handle full-cycle medical billing end-to-end. This ensures you don’t end up paying surprise ‘add-on’ fees when you need additional services.

#2 Who owns the payer portals and CAQH logins?

Why this question matters: Some vendors hold onto your logins, creating dependency. If you decide to switch vendors later, this can make transitions painful and lock you in.

What to look for: You should always own all payer portals, CAQH, and NPPES accounts, with credentials shared securely. This preserves long-term independence and control.

#3 What is your average timeline to get a provider enrolled?

Why this question matters: Every day lost in credentialing delays your ability to bill insurance. That directly impacts revenue.

What to look for: Transparency. A good vendor will share realistic, historical averages per payer (e.g., Medicare: 30 to 60 days, Medicaid: 60 to 120 days, commercial: 90 to 120 days). This allows your clinic to plan cash flow expectations accurately.

#4 Do you provide a dedicated point of contact?

Why this question matters: Without a named manager, communication becomes chaotic. Clinics may feel like they’re ‘in the dark’ on applications.

What to look for: A dedicated credentialing manager (plus backup) who offers weekly updates and same-day responses. This accountability reduces frustration and builds trust.

#5 What service level agreements (SLAs) do you commit to?

Why this question matters: Credentialing involves deadlines (CAQH attestations, re-credentialing, PSV requests). Without SLAs, vendors have no accountability.

What to look for: Specific commitments such as:

• Response time ≤ 1 business day
• CAQH updates within 3 business days
• PSV within 7 days
• Re-credentialing kickoff 120 days before the due date

This way, you have measurable standards to hold them accountable.

#6 How do you handle payer delays or denials?

Why this question matters: Applications can stall or be denied for reasons outside your control. Vendors who just ‘wait’ create backlogs.

What to look for: A vendor who escalates directly to payer reps, tracks case IDs, and provides root-cause reports. Ideally, if an error is theirs, they should rework it at no cost.

#7 How do you track progress and communicate status?

Why this question matters: Clinics can’t afford to constantly wonder, ‘What’s happening with our applications?” Lack of visibility creates stress.

What to look for: Vendors who offer a live dashboard with per-payer status, expected approval dates, and weekly emailed reports. Transparency here is a huge differentiator.

#8 Do you integrate with our EHR or Practice Management system?

Why this question matters: Duplicate data entry wastes time and increases the chance of errors.

What to look for: Vendors that integrate directly with your EHR/PM (e.g., OmniMD) or at least provide CSV/API exports. Flawless integration saves staff hours and ensures accuracy.

#9 How do you ensure compliance with HIPAA and NCQA?

Why this question matters: Credentialing involves highly sensitive provider data. If mishandled, it exposes your clinic to legal and compliance risks.

What to look for: Vendors who sign BAAs, use encryption, and align PSV processes with NCQA standards. This proves they treat compliance as non-negotiable.

#10 What happens if a claim is denied due to credentialing issues?

Why this question matters: Denials caused by credentialing errors result in revenue loss. If the vendor doesn’t take responsibility, you’re stuck with the consequences.

What to look for: A vendor who commits to fixing errors at no cost and provides corrective reporting. This accountability ensures they are invested in your clinic’s financial health.

Conclusion

No matter how much you invest in marketing, and no matter how skilled your providers are, if credentialing stalls, revenue never begins. Growth does not truly happen with a new exam room or a bigger front desk. It happens at the speed of payer approvals.

Credentialing is the hidden growth throttle. Ignore it and expansion chokes. Master it and you gain a competitive edge most clinics miss.

That is why choosing a credentialing partner is really choosing the pace of your growth. Ask the right questions, and you do not just sidestep delays. You define how fast your clinic can move, how boldly it can expand, and how sustainably it can win in a market where trust, revenue, and speed are inseparable.

Read Similar Article:

Top 5 Claim Scrubbing Software for Clinics